This article from the Los Angeles Times 5/9/13 discusses the issue of the tremendous cost variations for the same procedures in different hospitals. There are online tools which may be helpful to consumers who want to know costs for procedures. The bottom line is that there has to be more transparency and cost containment.

Medicare data on hospitals’ disparate prices spotlight ‘practices that don’t seem to make sense.’


New Medicare data reveal wildly varying charges among the nation’s hospitals for 100 of the most common in-patient treatments and procedures, calling into question medical billing practices just as U.S. officials try to rein in rising costs.

The escalating price of medical care may complicate the rollout of the new federal healthcare law, which is designed to make health insurance affordable for millions of uninsured Americans next year. And federal officials said they hope the data will encourage more price competition and make consumers better healthcare shoppers.

In the Los Angeles area, for instance, one hospital’s average price for knee and hip replacements in 2011 was as high as $223,373. That’s seven times as much as the lowest charge of $32,022 in the Southland.

The average hospital charge for treating pneumonia ranged from $17,000 to nearly $70,000 in the L.A. area.

“We want to shine a much brighter light on practices that don’t seem to make sense to us,” said Jonathan Blum, deputy administrator for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. “We do not see any business reason for why there is so much variation in the data.”

Hospitals said they support efforts to simplify an overly complex medical billing system and arm consumers with more information. The California Hospital Assn. agreed, but warned that the newly available federal data “may confuse patients as well as the public.”

Health-policy experts called the government’s move to release prices from more than 3,000 U.S. hospitals unprecedented in its scope, and they said it could accelerate related efforts to pry more detailed cost information from health insurers and other medical provid- ers.

Many employers and consumers still struggle to unravel the closely guarded secrets of medical pricing even though they are being asked to shell out ever-increasing amounts for care.

Medicare and private insurers pay only a fraction of these billed charges disclosed by the government. Regardless of the bills, Medicare pays standardized amounts for specific conditions, and insurers negotiate lower rates.

Nonetheless, experts say the actual amounts insurers and consumers pay follow a similar pattern of wildly divergent prices with little correlation to the quality of patient care or the underlying costs.

“This is evidence of an incredibly dysfunctional and arbitrary pricing system in healthcare,” said Renee Hsia, an assistant professor of emergency medicine at UC San Francisco who studies these cost variations. “It affects us all because the insured pay for this through their premiums and the uninsured face the sticker price. People are really being hurt by this.”

Critics say hospitals benefit from inflating these listed prices because some health insurers still peg their reimbursement to a percentage of full charges. They also say hospitals gain from higher charges by taking credit for writing off larger amounts for low-income and uninsured patients.

“There’s an incentive to have your charge as high as possible,” said Ateev Mehrotra, a policy analyst for Santa Monica-based Rand Corp.

The American Hospital Assn. said it supports efforts at greater transparency and noted that more than 40 states, including California, already require or encourage pricing information to be reported publicly.

“The complex and bewildering interplay among charges, rates, bills and payments across dozens of payers, public and private, does not serve any stakeholder well, including hospitals,” said Rich Umbdenstock, chief executive of the hospital trade group.

Researchers have documented for years some of the surprising variations in medical costs across the country and within the same city. But this move by Medicare marked the first time so much data on the topic were released directly to the public.

There are valid reasons for some disparity in costs, researchers say, such as geographic differences in the cost of living and wages or the fact that teaching hospi tals bear additional costs. Some hospitals also treat a higher percentage of low-income or sicker patients.

In Wednesday’s data, two Southern California hospitals held the dubious distinction of billing the highest amounts nationwide for a joint replacement surgery without complications.

Monterey Park Hospital charged $223,373 on average, and Centinela Hospital Medical Center in Inglewood billed $220,881.

In contrast, L.A. County Harbor/UCLA Medical Cen ter posted the lowest local rate — charging $32,022 for new artificial hips and knees.

Officials at Monterey Park couldn’t be reached. A spokesman for Prime Healthcare’s Centinela Hospital said the higher rate reflects “a sicker and older patient population” compared with other area hospitals.

Similar price disparities were seen in the treatment of simple pneumonia in the Southland. Providence Holy Cross Medical Center in Mission Hills billed $69,574, on average, for treating pneumonia without complications, federal data show. At the low end, L.A. County/ USC Medical Center billed $19,852, on average, for that illness, and Citrus Valley Medical Center charged $17,174.

As policyholders’ deductibles have risen and they have more of their own money at stake, insurers have introduced new online tools enabling members to get a range of prices among network providers. But consumer advocates still see significant resistance among hospitals and insurers to disclose detailed information.

“Everybody in the industry is so scared about what it would mean if all the pricing information was available,” said Suzanne Delbanco, executive director of Catalyst for Payment Reform, an employer-backed group in San Francisco pushing for more healthcare transparency. “Medicare is sending a message that American consumers have a right to know what’s driving up their healthcare costs.”

Comparing healthcare prices

With increasingly wide-ranging costs for medical procedures, here are some resources to help you find and understand medical prices.

Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services: Database shows charges for the 100 most common hospital-based treatments and procedures.

California Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development: Publishes California hospitals’ average charges for the 25 most common procedures.

Both of these government sites are complicated and full of jargon, and it may take considerable time to find the information you need. Also, the prices listed on both sites often may not reflect the actual costs of care, and only represent what a hospital charges Medicare, private insurers, and in some cases, patients with no insurance.

More consumer resources

There are a growing number of price comparison tools that can help consumers save money.

Your insurance carrier: Insurers typically offer pricing tools showing the average cost for many procedures within a geographic area or ZIP Code, or in some cases, the cost of receiving care from specific healthcare providers. If you get your insurance at work, check whether your employer offers healthcare pricing tools.

Online: There are also a number of private websites that enable you to get a ballpark figure for what medical procedures and services should cost, including:

8 Fair Health (  )

8 Healthcare Bluebook (  )

8 Health in Reach (  )

8 New Choice Health (  )

8 Cost Helper (  )



Get every new post on this blog delivered to your Inbox.

Join other followers:

The Dennis L. David Insurance Agency | Long Term Care Insurance, Los Angeles Medical Insurance, Anthem Blue Cross Healthcare Insurance, Whole & Term Life Insurance Policies, Cigna, Disability Insurance, Blue Shield of CA, Group Health Plans, Aetna, Group Medical Insurance, Skilled Nursing Insurance, Medicare Supplement Insurance, Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans, In-Home Care, Disabled Work Insurance, Disability Benefits, Culver City Health & Life Insurance, Family & Individual Health Insurance, Health Care Reform & Affordable Care Act Assistance, Obamacare, Covered CA Health Insurance, Health Plans, Kaiser Insurance, Genworth Life, John Hancock Life, Culver City Long Term Care & Disability, Employee Benefits, Beverly Hills, Hollywood, West Hollywood, Santa Monica, Pacific Palisades, Marina Del Rey, West Los Angeles, Los Angeles, El Segundo, Sherman Oaks, Encino, Los Angeles, Manhattan Beach, Los Angeles County CA, California

CA Insurance License Number:  0668857

TX Insurance License Number:  1774174